Günther Blumentritt

Günther Blumentritt (10 February 1892 – 12 October 1967) was a German officer in World War I, who became a Staff Officer under the Weimar Republic and went on to serve as a general for Nazi Germany during World War II. He served throughout the war, mostly on the Western Front, and mostly as a Staff Officer, though he was eventually given his own Corps and made a General der Infanterie. Blumentritt was instrumental in planning the 1939 German invasion of Poland and the 1940 invasion of France, he participated in Operation Barbarossa, and afterward bore a large part of the responsibility for planning the defense of the Atlantic Wall and Normandy. After the war, Blumentritt gave an affidavit at the Nuremberg Trials, though he never testified in person, and then later helped in the rearmament of Germany during the Cold War and the development of the modern German army.

Personal life and early career

Family and character

Born in Munich, Günther Alois Friedrich Blumentritt was the son of Günther Blumentritt (born 23 June 1859), town planner and a Privy Councilor in Munich and Lina Rückart (born 24 March 1868). In 1920, he married Mathilde Schollmeyer, and subsequently had two children with her; they remained married 47 years, until her death in 1967.^[1] Blumentritt was described as the opposite in many ways of his long-time commander Gerd von Rundstedt: Bavarian and Catholic,^[2] where von Rundstedt was Prussian and Protestant; swarthy and short where von Rundstedt was tall and pale. Blumentritt was affable, friendly, and talkative, capable of great diplomacy, and in military terms, detail oriented—all of which made him an excellent staff officer, as well as a good complement to von Rundstedt.^[3]

Early military career

He joined the German Army in 1911, in time for World War I, entering the 3rd Thuringian Infantry Regiment No. 71. as a Fahnenjunker. In 1912, he attended the Danzig Kriegsakademie (War Academy), and shortly afterward was promoted to Leutnant.^[1] He was conferred the command of his first regiment on 20 February 1919. During the war, he served mostly on the Eastern Front in Prussia, after a brief contact with the French and Belgians at Namur in August, 1914.^[4] In August 1918, he was wounded in action and received the Wound Badge in black. By the end of the war he was a Oberleutnant.^[1][5][6]

Blumentritt′s experiences on the Eastern Front in World War I gave him a great deal of respect for the Russian soldiers. He maintained this respect throughout his career, and regretted that many of his fellow officers, with less experience in the East, did not share it. He said of the Russians, "... in defense the Imperial Russian Army was stubborn and tenacious and they were masters at constructing defensive positions with great speed. The Russian soldier showed great skill in night operations and in forest fighting, and he preferred hand-to-hand combat. His physical needs were slight and his ability to stand up to punishment unshaken truly astounding."^[7]

Later, during the interwar period Blumentritt served as a company leader in 3rd Thuringian Infantry Regiment No. 71 from 20 February 1919. After the military restrictions imposed by the Treaty of Versailles came into effect, he was briefly a member of the Freikorps (paramilitary organization) formed by the veterans of the 3rd Thuringian, before transferring back to the regular army with the 22nd Reichswehr Rifle Regiment on 1 October 1919. Then later he served as a staff officer in several positions, first as operations command officer from 1 April 1926 in the staff of the 6th Division. He was promoted to Major in September, 1933, then worked as a lecturer and tactics instructor at the Kriegsakademie in 1935, and finally was promoted to Oberst in October 1938. He eventually served as a staff officer under Wilhelm Ritter von Leeb, along with his friend Erich von Manstein.^[1]

World War II

German invasions

On 7 May 1939, Blumentritt submitted to his superiors a working plan for the German Invasion of Poland. At this time, he was assigned to the Oberkommando des Heeres (Army High Command; OKH), and formed along with von Manstein and Generalfeldmarshall Gerd von Rundstedt a "Working Staff" for the development of a plan for the invasion. The plan he submitted was called Fall Weiss (Case White). It was subsequently to be followed with little alteration.^[8] Then on 2 September 1939, Blumentritt was transferred to the general staff of the Army Group South (one of the two German Army Groups to carry out the invasion) in Silesia under von Rundstedt. This collaboration began his long and intimate friendship with von Runstedt, which was to last for many years. Blumentritt was von Rundstedt′s Chief of Operations, while von Manstein was Chief of Staff.^[9] The invasion was put into motion, after some delays, on 1 September 1939, and by 6 October the entire country of Poland was subdued.^[10]

In 1940, Blumentritt—as the Operations Officer of Army Group A (again under von Rundstedt)—took part in the planning (with von Manstein and Henning von Tresckow) and execution of the invasion of France. The plan he helped develop was called Sichelschnitt or "Sickle Cut", and was later referred to as the Manstein Plan. The subsequent unmitigated success of the German Blitzkrieg in France and the complete collapse of the French defense shocked even the Germans.^[11] However, as the German army closed in on complete victory, Blumentritt and von Rundstedt ignored conflicting orders from the OKH to advance on the British and French position at Dunkirk, and instead followed Adolf Hitler′s order to halt for three days, consequently allowing the evacuation of the British Forces.^[12][13]

Immediately after the German occupation of France, von Rundstedt, Blumentritt, and others were tasked with preparing for the invasion of Great Britain. This plan, as handed down from high command, was designated Operation Sea Lion. Blumentritt helped with the details of the plan, and several exercises were carried out in preparation for it, but he never believed that it was a serious option, or that Hitler intended to carry it out. He said that at the end of July or August "...Field-Marshal von Rundstedt was in Berlin, and Hitler stated quite clearly to him that he did not intend to carry out Sea Lion," and further, "By the end of September it was clear that the invasion of England was off."^[2]

In 1941, Blumentritt, under General Günther von Kluge—was made Chief of Staff of the 4. Armee and promoted to general,^[14] and despite the opposition he later professed to the plan, was involved with the German invasion of the Soviet Union. On 18 April 1941, Blumentritt wrote:

Maybe the Russians really intend to stand and fight the Germans between the western border and the Dnieper, a move which would be desirable...Even the Imperial Army was no match for the German command, and the Russian commanders today are at an even greater disadvantage. The shortcomings of the middle ranks are even greater...The effects of German weapons, whose prestige has increased with the campaign against Yugoslavia, will soon be felt! There will be fourteen days of heavy fighting. Hopefully, by then we shall have made it.^[15]

In another memo, Blumentritt wrote:

On warfare and the inner value of the Russian opponent, the dull mass had two kinds of "ideas": the tsar and God. Today, there is neither. Bolshevism has taken their place. I consider that to be a weakness since I never believed that this idea means anything to the bulk of the Russian people. That is why I do not believe that the people will be carried away by Bolshevism. They will soon be indifferent and fatalistic.^[16]

Blumentritt′s command was part of Army Group Center, which suffered massive casualties and the 4th Army itself only narrowly escaped envelopment and annihilation by the Russians outside Moscow.^[17][18] After the ultimate failure of Operation Barbarossa in January 1942, Blumentritt returned to Germany as Chief Quartermaster of the OKH. Late in the year he personally recommended to his superiors that the Germans should withdraw from Stalingrad, receiving the support of Chief of Staff OKH—General Franz Halder—in this recommendation, but the idea of any withdrawal was rejected by Hitler.^[19]

Normandy and the July Plot

In September 1942, Blumentritt was made Chief of Staff to von Rundstedt, overall commander of German forces in the west (OB West).^[20] In this capacity, he was responsible for much of the planning to defend France against Allied invasion,^[6] and in 1943 he sent a memo to the OKH expressing his concern about the depletion of German forces along the Atlantic Wall as the Eastern Front continued to bleed resources from the West.^[21] During the invasion of Normandy in 1944, he and his commander were taken by surprise at the location of the landings on the Cherbourg peninsula, later saying, "The disposition would more truly be described as ′coast protection′ rather than ′defense′! As we did not anticipate that any landing would be made on the west side of the Cherbourg peninsula, that sector was held very lightly—we even put Russian units there."^[22]

Von Rundstedt was relieved of his command by Hitler on 2 July 2, 1944, after suggesting that Germany should surrender, and was replaced as OB West by von Kluge. Blumentritt served as Chief of Staff under von Kluge during the Anglo-Canadian offensive on Caen and the fighting in the Falaise Pocket.^[23] However, in July 1944, Blumentritt was implicated, along with von Kluge in the July 1944 conspiracy to kill Hitler; the plot failed, resulting in the arrest of many Army officers. Blumentritt himself was removed from his position (and von Kluge committed suicide on 17 August),^[23] but he survived the purge because Hitler did not believe him guilty,^[6] and in fact later awarded him the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross (Ritterkreuz des Eisernen Kreuzes) for his services.^[24]

Additionally, Blumentritt acted as a kind of ambassador between the SS and the Wehrmacht in France after the coup attempt. Over 1,000 SS officers—including the head of the SS in France, Carl Oberg, and the head of the SS Security Service in Paris, Helmut Knochen—had been arrested by the German military commander in France, Carl-Heinrich von Stülpnagel, who was complicit in the plot. This presented a problem for the Army when it was revealed that Hitler was still alive and in charge. After a meeting in Paris, Blumentritt was able to work out a deal with Oberg and Knochen whereby relations were patched up between the Army and the SS, and the involvement of many of the conspirators in Paris was never discovered.^[25]

Combat command and German surrender

Shortly after the upheaval associated with the assassination attempt, Blumentritt returned to his position as Chief of Staff of OB West, first under Generalfeldmarshall Walter Model,^[26] then once again under von Rundstedt when he was restored to command.^[27] However, he now served as a field commander rather than a staff officer, as he had been removed from his post as Chief of Staff and given a combat command^[28] and after being shuffled around to the LXXXVI Armeekorps and the LVII Panzerkorps, he was tapped as leader of "Corps Group Blumentritt" consisting of the XII SS Armeekorps (made up of the 176. Infantrie under Oberst Landau and the 183. Volksgrenadier under General Lange).^[29]

Under Model and then the restored von Rundstedt, the German army fell back, defending the Siegfried Line. Blumentritt and his command bore responsibility for almost 22 mi (35 km) of front northwest of Loverich (now part of Baesweiler) through Geilenkirchen all the way to the Maas River. After the Allied victory just to the south in the Battle of the Bulge, they turned their attention north to Blumentritt′s position. Subsequently, he and the XII SS Korps failed in their attempt to hold the salient of the Roer Triangle during the British Operation Blackcock.^[29][30]

On 29 January 1945 (not long after the collapse of the Roer Triangle), Blumentritt was appointed commander of the 25th Armee in the Netherlands,^[14] and all ground combat units in the country, not only of the Army, but also of the Navy and Air Force were brought together under this army. The army was tasked with holding Holland as a "fortress" under all circumstances. Blumentritt presented his assessment to von Rundstedt that the Allied forces, in the aftermath of the failed attempt to swing north through Arnhem, would bypass Holland and cross the Rhine further south (an accurate prediction), thus cutting off the forces in Holland. However, Hitler refused to evacuate the country and consequently the German forces in Holland later fell into Allied hands without a major battle.^[31] It was also during this time that Blumentritt received the Oak leaves (Eichenlaub) to the Knights Cross of the Iron Cross. He was the 741st person to receive this award.^[1]

Later, the Germans were pushed back to the Ruhr and, after the war Blumentritt disagreed with the Allies′ strategy in the west, discussing the precarious nature of the German position with its meager one armoured division against the Allies′ 12, and he stated that had Sir Bernard Montgomery been unleashed earlier for a concentrated armoured assault (as he wished) rather than fighting on a broad front, "Such a breakthrough ... would have torn the weak German front to pieces and ended the war in the winter of 1944."^[32]

On 27 March 1945, Blumentritt briefly assumed command of the increasingly demoralized^[31] 1st Parachute Army^[14] and then, from 8 April commanded "Army Group Blumentritt"—an ad-hoc collection of depleted units on the Weser river from Hameln to the Baltic Sea—up to the end of the war. He was tasked to delay the Anglo-Canadian advance into northern Germany and he attempted to keep the Baltic sea ports open as long as possible so that German refugees could escape from the Russian advance in the east. After the death of Hitler on 2 May, Blumentritt ordered his men to give no further resistance to the allies and to fall back gradually.^[31] In early May, Blumentritt acted as a first emissary to Montgomery for the surrender of the German forces in the North-West.^[33]

After the war

After capitulation on 5 May, Blumentritt and his command cooperated in demobilization, under orders from the British 2nd Army, and the taking of prisoners did not take place until 1 June. He was captured in Schleswig-Holstein and was placed in a British prisoner-of-war camp by 1 December,^[31] was interrogated by the International Military Tribunal for the Nuremberg Trials in 1946,^[34] and was then moved to a U.S. POW camp where he remained from 6 November 1947 until 1 January 1948. During this time as a POW, he assisted the U.S. Historical Division in Germany.^[2]

In the early 1950s, he was active in the development of the new Bundeswehr army, though this rearmament was a controversial move among the civilian population of Germany, who felt they had been victimized by World War II.^[35] He was used as a military adviser for the 1962 film The Longest Day, in which he was also portrayed by actor Curd Jürgens.^[36] He died on October 12, 1967 in Munich. He published several books before his death:

• Von Rundstedt, the soldier and the man, 1952
• Deutsches Soldatentum im europäischen Rahmen ("German Soldiership in a European Context"), 1952
• Strategie und Taktik : ein Beitrag zur Geschichte des Wehrwesens vom Altertum bis zur Gegenwart ("Strategy and Tactics: A Contribution to the History of Defense from Antiquity until Present"), 1960
• Schlacht um Moskau. Erinnerungen über die Heeresgruppe Mitte ("Battle of Moscow. Remembrances of the Army Group Middle"). (In: Seymour Freiden & William Richardson (editors): The Fatal Decisions. New York, 1958.)

Awards and promotions

Awards^[1]

• Iron Cross (1914) First and Second Class
• Cross of Honor of Schwarzburg 3rd Class with swords on 3 January 1915
• Knight's Cross of the Royal House Order of Hohenzollern with swords on 7 July 1918
• Wound Badge in Black in August, 1918
• Clasp to the Iron Cross Second and First Class
• German Cross in Gold on 26 January 1942
• Eastern Front Medal 1941/42 on 7 August 1942
• Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves
  • Knight's Cross on 13 September 1944 as General der Infanterie and chief of the general staff of the Heeresgruppe D^[37]
  • Oak Leaves, 18 February 1945 (741st Award) as General der Infanterie and acting commander of the 25th Army^[38]

Notes

References

• Blumentritt, Günther (January, 1949) "Operation Sealion" An Cosantoir[1]
• Blumentritt, Günther (March, 1949) "The Battle of Northwest Germany" An Cosantoir[2]
• Bradley, Dermont; Hildebrand, Karl-Friedrich; Rovekamp, Markus (1993) Die Generale des Heeres, 1921-1945, Biblio Verlag ISBN 3-7648-2422-0
• Cole, Hugh M. (1950) The Lorraine Campaign. United States Army Center of Military History[3]
• Cooper, Matthew (1978) The German Army: 1933-1945, Scarborough House ISBN 0-8128-8519-8
• Cornelius, Ryan (1974) A Bridge Too Far, Book Club Associates ISBN 978-1-4450-8373-5
• Dupuy, Johnson, & Bongard (1992) The Harper Encyclopedia of Military Biography, HarperCollins ISBN 0-06-270015-4
• Evans, Richard J. (2008) The Third Reich at War, Penguin Books ISBN 978-0-14-311671-4
• Fellgiebel, Walther-Peer (2000). Die Träger des Ritterkreuzes des Eisernen Kreuzes 1939-1945 (in German). Friedburg, Germany: Podzun-Pallas. ISBN 3-7909-0284-5
• Fellgiebel, Walther-Peer (2003) The Elite of the Third Reich: The Recipients of the Knights Cross of the Iron Cross 1939-1945, Helion ISBN 1-874622-46-9
• Freiden, Seymour & Richardson, William, editors (1956) The Fatal Decisions, Berkley Pub.
• Harrison, Gordon A. (1951) Cross Channel Attack, United States Army Center of Military History[4]
• Hart, Basil Lidell (1968) The Other Side of the Hill, C Chivers ISBN 978-0-85594-061-4
• Hart, Basil Lidell (1971) German Generals Talk, Harper ISBN 978-0-688-06012-1
• International Military Tribunal (June 24, 1946) G.S. & OKW Affidavit No. 610. Gen Blumentritt, Columbia Law Library [5]
• Internet Movie Database (Retrieved May 12, 2010) The Longest Day 1962 at the Internet Movie Database
• Lewis, S.J. (1985) Forgotten Legions: German Army Infantry Policy 1918-1941, Praeger Pub. ISBN 978-0-275-90235-3
• MacDonald, Charles B. (1963) The Siegfried Line Campaign, United States Army Center of Military History ISBN 978-0-16-080075-7 [6]
• Reuters (May 5, 1945) "Germans Surrender in North-West" The Times
• Schaulen, Fritjof (2003). Eichenlaubträger 1940 - 1945 Zeitgeschichte in Farbe I Abraham - Huppertz (in German). Selent, Germany: Pour le Mérite. ISBN 3-932381-20-3.
• Searle, Alaric (2003) Wehrmacht Generals, West German Society, and the Debate on Rearmament, 1949-1959, Praeger Pub. ISBN 978-0-275-97968-3
• Shirer, William L. (1959) The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich: A History of Nazi Germany, Simon & Schuster ISBN 0-671-72868-7
• Shulman, Milton (1948) Defeat in the West, E.P. Dutton ISBN 0837156386
• U.S 43rd Infantry Division HQ (January 15, 1945) Report on Operation Blackcock[7]
• Wilmot, Chester (1952) The Struggle for Europe, Collins (re-issued by Wordsworth 1998) ISBN 978-1-85326-677-5

External links

• Günther Blumentritt in the German National Library catalogue (German)
• Spartacus Educational entry on Blumentritt
• ww2awards.com list of awards
• Island Farm POW Camp entry for Blumentritt
• generals.dk entry with list of positions